Apple, Microsoft, others battle for your living room
Apple Corp. (formerly Apple Computer Corp.) recently announced not only their snazzy new iPhone (and promptly got sued by Cisco for stealing the name), but also revealed details on the Apple TV, beginning Apple’s move from the computer and the pocket to the living room, where they’ll have to compete with the likes of Microsoft, Akimbo, MovieBeam, and even TiVo and the cable TV companies.
After looking through the press releases and news stories on the Apple TV, which has not received nearly so much press as the iPhone, I thought it might be helpful to break down the differences between the Apple TV and an Xbox 360, since both devices are designed to bridge the gap between computers and living room entertainment, and since it’s always fun to pit Apple against Microsoft. With that goal in mind, here are some of the stats, side-by-side:
| Apple TV | XBOX 360/XBOX Live |
| $299 | $399 w/hard drive |
| $299 w/o hard drive | |
| 40GB hard drive | 20GB hard drive |
| copies media from computer (i.e., requires a computer to do anything) | streams media from computer |
| play media (audio, video, images) from Mac or Windows PC with iTunes | play media (audio, video, images) from Windows PC with Media Center or Windows Media Player 10 |
| buy media on computer | buy media on computer or on console |
| keep media as long as you want (for now) | purchased media expires; ripped media does not |
| movies and TV shows from: Paramount, Disney, NBC, MTV, Showtime, ABC, CBS, SciFi, Comedy Central, Nickelodeon, others | movies and TV shows from: Paramount, Warner Bros, ABC, adult swim, CBS, Comedy Central, MTV, NBC, Nickelodeon, Spike, UFC, VH1 |
| near-DVD quality video downloads via iTunes | DVD or HD quality downloads on console |
| Cost: Movies for $9.99 and up (new releases are higher); 200+ TV shows at $1.99 an episode. | Cost: Movies $4-$6; TV shows $2 |
| does not play video games | plays video games |
| no chat functionality | chat with others via included audio headset or purchase video camera ($39.99, excluding required Gold-level yearly subscription to XBOX Live) |
| does not play DVDs | plays DVDs (regular or HD-DVD with $199 add=on) |
| cannot plug in other devices (yet – does include ports for this) | plug in digital cameras or MP3 player (including iPod) |
| built-in wifi or plug in to home network | must purchase wifi adapter for $99.99 or plug in to home network |
| remote control included | remote control included (or purchase $29.99 universal remote control) |
| 7.7" x 7.7" x 1.1" | 12.15" x 3.27" x 10.15" |
| supports HDMI connections | does not support HDMI (yet) |
For either option, the DRM (digital rights management) needs to be a consideration. The Apple TV can only play iTunes media, while the Xbox 360 cannot play iTunes media. Thus if all your media is already stuck in the formats used by Apple, then you’ll have to use either an Apple TV or an Apple computer to play the media. That really only pertains to media purchased through the iTunes store of course – the CDs that you ripped should play through pretty much anything. If you use a Mac, though, you won’t be able to stream your media in any format to an Xbox.
If you haven’t purchased anything through the iTunes store, or if you have video in non-QuickTime formats such as Divx, then a Xbox 360 should be able to play your media. A problem with the Xbox 360 is the need to subscribe to the Xbox Live Gold service. That’s not a requirement to play media from your PC; it is a requirement to purchase media directly through your Xbox. A year’s subscription costs $49.99.
The Xbox360, can, of course, play video games, DVDs, and other media on its own. The Apple TV is basically a larger, non-portable iPod, minus the click-wheel. Because of this, and because the box retails for $299, some have suggested that you just hook up a computer, such as a Mac Mini, to your TV if you want to play iTunes media on your television. You can check out a comparison between Apple TV and the Mac Mini here.
Personally, the only compelling reason to get an Apple TV, unless you enjoy having ten different devices plugged into your television, is if all of your media is locked into the proprietary iTunes (“FairPlay”) format. The Apple TV is nowhere near a DVR or a media PC (like Windows Media Center). If all you’re looking for is to stream your music and videos, and if your media isn’t locked down by DRM technologies like FairPlay — which seem to mostly just prevent Fair Use — then there are other devices, besides an Apple TV, that can cover your needs, and soon you should be able to get your iTunes media off your computer and onto other devices. Those devices just won’t be made by Apple, and my bet is that Apple is not going to license the technology to Microsoft. So why not just pass on the Apple TV and wait for a DVR that can not only stream your iTunes media, but also play the latest, recorded episodes of your favorite shows. I wonder if you’ll be able to watch something like this weekends Saints v Bears playoff game, while you listen to your own soundtrack? If an Xbox 360 can let you play your own soundtrack during video games (not that you’d want to do anything to the Halo music), surely someone will let you do that with recorded television.
Share ThisPosted in tech | 2 Comments »
January 20th, 2007 at 10:04 pm
Do I detect an angle…a slight one at that, but a slight angle leaning against Apple (Fairplay preventing Fair Use!…that’s a nice word play though!) Although hey that’s what a blog is for am I right!?!?!
This IS incredibly interesting! Thank you. I hadn’t heard about this.
January 20th, 2007 at 11:06 pm
Perhaps what you detect as “an angle” is really just due to my actual disappointment in Apple’s new product. Months ago, when I first heard of the Apple TV, I expected something really snazzy — think Tivo meets iTunes meets something else new — the point being that Apple had an opportunity to move the ball forward, when all they really did was keep things where they were.
Microsoft’s Xbox 360 is a decent example of what a company (with a lot of resources) can do in the area of home entertainment. Apple really did have an opportunity to take the experience of having your media in your living room to another level. What they did was simply make your media play in your living room. That’s certainly worth something; it’s just not what I was looking for!